Gardner Pie Company: Food Recall in 2016 - (Recall #: F-2244-2016)

Updated on March 25, 2026.

See the recall detail below. You can also see other recalls from the same firm in 2016.

Data Source: FDA.

Product Description:

Product is a 32-ounce Key Lime pie sold at the firm's retail outlet only. Pie is packed in a cardboard carton with an aluminum pie pan and a plastic dome lid. Retail pie is not labeled. Customers are provided the flavor of pie they select for purchase.

Product Classification:

Class II

Date Initiated: June 17, 2016

Date Posted: September 21, 2016

Recall Number: F-2244-2016

Event ID: 74470

Reason for Recall:

The firm was notified by their supplier of graham cracker crumbs that the flour used to manufacture the crumbs was potentially contaminated with peanut residue. The graham cracker crumbs are used in the production of key lime pie, and cheesecake. The crumbs are used to make the bottom crust of pie and cheesecake.

Status: Terminated

Product Quantity: 163 individual pies

Code Information:

No codes on pies.

Distribution Pattern:

The state of Ohio only

Voluntary or Mandated:

Voluntary: Firm initiated