Totally Cool, Inc.: Food Recall in 2024 - (Recall #: F-1557-2024)

Updated on March 25, 2026.

See the recall detail below. You can also see other recalls from the same firm in 2024.

Data Source: FDA.

Product Description:

The Frozen Farmer Santa's Cookies Ice Cream Cookie Sandwich the Elf On the Shelf 4 fl oz UPC 850023398178. Individually wrapped in plastic, 4 sandwiches packaged in a cardboard box, 24 boxes per case.

Product Classification:

Class II

Date Initiated: June 13, 2024

Date Posted: August 7, 2024

Recall Number: F-1557-2024

Event ID: 94829

Reason for Recall:

Possible contamination with Listeria monocytogenes

Status: Terminated

Product Quantity: 26453 cases

Code Information:

All Best by Dates Between: 09/04/25 to 12/07/25 Plant Code: 24-65

Distribution Pattern:

Distributed nationwide.

Voluntary or Mandated:

Voluntary: Firm initiated