Butler, NY - Most Valuable Residential Properties in 2024
Updated on November 21, 2025.
According to data from official New York government agencies, among residential properties in Butler, NY, the following were the most valuable residential properties by Market Value in 2024. The most valuable residential property was 5941 Muckland Ave ($400.00K), followed by 5095 Westbury Rd ($364.60K), 11905 Salter Colvin Rd ($352.80K), and 4619 Whiskey Hill Rd ($352.80K).
The chart below shows the top 10 valuable residential properties, and the table below shows the top 200.
You can see similar information for other New York cities.
You may also be interested in:
Data Source: Official Government Sites.
Butler, NY - Most Valuable Residential Properties in 2024
Items per page:
25
0 of 0
| Address | Market Value ($) |
|---|---|
| 5941 Muckland Ave, Butler, NY 13143 | 400000 |
| 5095 Westbury Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 364600 |
| 11905 Salter Colvin Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 352800 |
| 4619 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 352800 |
| 13226 Pond Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 351600 |
| 5295 Muckland Ave, Butler, NY 13143 | 341600 |
| 5931 Wager Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 341100 |
| 5851 Auburn St, Butler, NY 14590 | 332800 |
| 4000 Foster Mead Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 329400 |
| 4671 Westbury Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 326900 |
| 14010 Westbury Cutoff Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 311800 |
| 4006 Reed Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 305800 |
| 4770 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 303400 |
| 13296 McCann Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 298800 |
| 5825 Muckland Ave, Butler, NY 13143 | 294000 |
| 14203 Westbury Cutoff Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 292900 |
| 4515 Westbury Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 284700 |
| 4647 Saeli Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 284100 |
| 4595 Drury Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 282200 |
| 3707 Montana Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 280000 |
| 4667 Lasher Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 277500 |
| 4885 Butler Center Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 270500 |
| 12206 Smith Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 268200 |
| 5735 Muckland Ave, Butler, NY 13143 | 265900 |
| 4225 Butler Center Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 258800 |
| 4953 Westbury Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 258700 |
| 4945 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 254100 |
| 5766 New Hartford St, Butler, NY 14590 | 247100 |
| 4410 Lasher Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 245900 |
| 5227 Westbury Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 241100 |
| 14109 Westbury Cutoff Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 233100 |
| 12497 Countryman Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 229300 |
| 12915 Washburn Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 226900 |
| 3971 Saeli Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 226900 |
| 4396 Lasher Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 225900 |
| 11971 Salter Colvin Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 223400 |
| 4800 Butler Center Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 223400 |
| 5213 Hogback Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 223400 |
| 5836 Spring Green Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 222400 |
| 4622 Livingston Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 220000 |
| 4822 Westbury Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 219882 |
| 5470 Spring Green Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 218200 |
| 3630 Drury Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 217600 |
| 4620 Crane Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 216200 |
| 4153 Foster Mead Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 215900 |
| 4250 Montana Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 215200 |
| 4408 Butler Center Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 214100 |
| 4562 Lasher Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 211800 |
| 5773 Muckland Ave, Butler, NY 13143 | 211800 |
| 4632 Saeli Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 211600 |
| 5271 Westbury Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 211600 |
| 5307 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 211600 |
| 5825 Limekiln Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 209400 |
| 13127 Pond Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 205900 |
| 11684 Salter Colvin Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 205800 |
| 3701 Slyburg Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 204700 |
| 5100 Miller Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 204600 |
| 5027 Crane Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 203400 |
| 13100 Pond Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 200000 |
| 4616 Lasher Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 198800 |
| 4840 Westbury Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 198700 |
| 4728 Westbury Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 197294 |
| 5033 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 195200 |
| 4514 Saeli Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 188200 |
| 5641 Muckland Ave, Butler, NY 13143 | 188200 |
| 5947 Muckland Ave, Butler, NY 13143 | 188100 |
| 4536 Butler Center Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 187100 |
| 13635 Wolcott Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 182400 |
| 4768 Butler Center Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 182400 |
| 5048 Gaylord Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 182200 |
| 5455 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 181200 |
| 3914 Montana Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 179900 |
| 4018 Slyburg Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 178800 |
| 4413 Lasher Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 178800 |
| 5897 Auburn St, Butler, NY 14590 | 178800 |
| 4546 Paylor Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 178200 |
| 4809 Reitz Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 177500 |
| 12237 Smith Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 176500 |
| 12978 Deigel Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 176500 |
| 5463 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 176500 |
| 5557 Muckland Ave, Butler, NY 13143 | 176500 |
| 5616 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 176400 |
| 5312 Hogback Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 175200 |
| 3690 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 174100 |
| 4211 Slyburg Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 174100 |
| 5043 Reitz Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 170600 |
| 5106 Reitz Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 170600 |
| 5865 New Hartford St, Butler, NY 14590 | 169300 |
| 4705 Lasher Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 168100 |
| 5515 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 167800 |
| 4088 Saeli Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 164700 |
| 4504 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 164700 |
| 4728 Lasher Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 164700 |
| 5259 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 164700 |
| 14206 Westbury Cutoff Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 164600 |
| 5732 Spring Green Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 164600 |
| 5903 Williams St, Butler, NY 14590 | 164200 |
| 4991 Butler Center Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 163400 |
| 5535 Wager Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 162400 |
| 5907 New Hartford St, Butler, NY 14590 | 161100 |
| 5005 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 160000 |
| 4817 Westbury Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 159900 |
| 5839 Sunset Ter, Butler, NY 14590 | 159900 |
| 11753 Salter Colvin Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 158800 |
| 12071 Salter Colvin Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 158800 |
| 4781 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 158700 |
| 5490 Limekiln Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 157600 |
| 5800 Auburn St, Butler, NY 14590 | 157600 |
| 5831 Westbury Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 156400 |
| 5374 Limekiln Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 155300 |
| 11957 Wilson St, Butler, NY 14590 | 152900 |
| 12385 Countryman Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 152900 |
| 4900 Miller Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 152800 |
| 5594 Wager Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 152800 |
| 3649 Slyburg Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 151800 |
| 11926 Wilson St, Butler, NY 14590 | 151600 |
| 6009 Muckland Ave, Butler, NY 13143 | 151200 |
| 4614 Drury Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 150600 |
| 12419 Countryman Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 147100 |
| 4050 Saeli Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 147100 |
| 4194 Saeli Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 147100 |
| 4507 Paylor Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 147100 |
| 3580 Drury Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 146900 |
| 5905 Draper St, Butler, NY 14590 | 146900 |
| 12546 Countryman Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 145900 |
| 5348 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 143400 |
| 11910 Butler St, Butler, NY 14590 | 142400 |
| 5834 Sunset Ter, Butler, NY 14590 | 142400 |
| 4808 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 142200 |
| 5452 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 141800 |
| 11840 Wilson St, Butler, NY 14590 | 141200 |
| 4518 Lasher Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 141200 |
| 5176 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 141200 |
| 14194 Westbury Cutoff Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 141100 |
| 3928 Montana Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 141100 |
| 4850 Westbury Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 141100 |
| 4854 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 141100 |
| 5347 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 141100 |
| 5385 Reitz Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 141100 |
| 11800 Wilson St, Butler, NY 14590 | 140000 |
| 4168 Livingston Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 140000 |
| 5845 Muckland Ave, Butler, NY 13143 | 140000 |
| 4833 Livingston Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 139900 |
| 3800 Yates Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 139400 |
| 11881 Wilson St, Butler, NY 14590 | 138800 |
| 12052 Willow Ln, Butler, NY 14590 | 138800 |
| 12305 Countryman Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 138800 |
| 5361 Muckland Ave, Butler, NY 13143 | 138800 |
| 11913 Butler St, Butler, NY 14590 | 137500 |
| 3392 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 137500 |
| 5838 New Hartford St, Butler, NY 14590 | 137500 |
| 5627 Wager Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 136900 |
| 12291 Countryman Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 136500 |
| 12319 Countryman Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 136500 |
| 4116 Drury Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 136400 |
| 4840 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 136400 |
| 5275 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 136400 |
| 12998 Bassett Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 135300 |
| 4509 Drury Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 135200 |
| 3903 Yates Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 132800 |
| 4640 Westbury Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 132800 |
| 5217 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 132800 |
| 5984 Muckland Ave, Butler, NY 13143 | 132800 |
| 5839 Muckland Ave, Butler, NY 13143 | 132400 |
| 5327 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 132000 |
| 11906 Butler St, Butler, NY 14590 | 131800 |
| 13042 Pond Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 131800 |
| 3625 Drury Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 131800 |
| 5823 Sunset Ter, Butler, NY 14590 | 131800 |
| 5863 Delf Dr, Butler, NY 14590 | 131800 |
| 4494 Lasher Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 131400 |
| 3723 Montana Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 129400 |
| 5809 New Hartford St, Butler, NY 14590 | 129400 |
| 5919 New Hartford St, Butler, NY 14590 | 129400 |
| 4659 Butler Center Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 129300 |
| 5241 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 128200 |
| 5024 Westbury Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 128100 |
| 5674 Limekiln Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 128100 |
| 5848 Limekiln Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 128100 |
| 3681 Livingston Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 127100 |
| 3728 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 127100 |
| 14104 Westbury Cutoff Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 125800 |
| 4316 Drury Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 124600 |
| 4507 Drury Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 124600 |
| 3685 Montana Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 123500 |
| 5151 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 123500 |
| 5514 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 123500 |
| 5773 New Hartford St, Butler, NY 14590 | 123500 |
| 5849 New Hartford St, Butler, NY 14590 | 123500 |
| 13240 Wolcott Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 123400 |
| 13212 Wolcott Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 122400 |
| 12409 Countryman Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 121100 |
| 12500 Countryman Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 121100 |
| 14215 Westbury Cutoff Rd, Butler, NY 13143 | 121100 |
| 3619 Drury Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 121100 |
| 4261 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 13146 | 121100 |
| 4348 Butler Center Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 121100 |
| 5085 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 121100 |
| 5180 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 121100 |
| 5453 Whiskey Hill Rd, Butler, NY 14590 | 121100 |