Columbus, NY - Most Valuable Residential Properties in 2024
Updated on November 21, 2025.
According to data from official New York government agencies, among residential properties in Columbus, NY, the following were the most valuable residential properties by Market Value in 2024. The most valuable residential property was 124 Church Rd ($620.34K), followed by 789 Spurr St ($578.65K), 631 Columbus Hill Rd ($443.15K), and 270 Pope Hill Rd ($362.70K).
The chart below shows the top 10 valuable residential properties, and the table below shows the top 165.
You can see similar information for other New York cities.
You may also be interested in:
Data Source: Official Government Sites.
Columbus, NY - Most Valuable Residential Properties in 2024
Items per page:
25
0 of 0
| Address | Market Value ($) |
|---|---|
| 124 Church Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 620337 |
| 789 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 578652 |
| 631 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 443146 |
| 270 Pope Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 362697 |
| 339 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 350787 |
| 426 Walt Phillips Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 342697 |
| 336 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 314382 |
| 366 Holdredge Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 312135 |
| 465 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 292022 |
| 361 Pope Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 284045 |
| 213 Sears Pond Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 280899 |
| 497 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 275281 |
| 206 Norton Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 265955 |
| 218 Bell Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 264045 |
| 310 Fusch Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 251910 |
| 244 Kelley Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 250787 |
| 213 Button Rd, Columbus, NY 13485 | 249438 |
| 289 Winton Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 244944 |
| 272 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 241573 |
| 646 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 241573 |
| 119 Davis Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 240787 |
| 277 Kelley Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 235169 |
| 138 Sears Pond Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 230337 |
| 430 Winton Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 224719 |
| 120 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 223596 |
| 279 Rock Calhoun Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 223596 |
| 397 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 222247 |
| 276 Balcom Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 220899 |
| 299 Walt Phillips Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 212247 |
| 414 Casey Cheese Factory Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 208989 |
| 209 Church Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 208202 |
| 266 Mordas Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 207865 |
| 739 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 202247 |
| 217 Mordas Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 202135 |
| 219 Mordas Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 202135 |
| 315 Norton Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 200000 |
| 201 Walt Phillips Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 196854 |
| 122 Sears Pond Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 196629 |
| 442 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 196629 |
| 355 Winton Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 185393 |
| 189 Mordas Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 183146 |
| 675 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 183146 |
| 385 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 182809 |
| 271 Sears Pond Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 179775 |
| 197 Barnard Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 179213 |
| 165 Prohaska Ln, Columbus, NY 13411 | 176966 |
| 118 Hemlock Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 176742 |
| 168 Holdredge Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 176180 |
| 140 Casey Cheese Factory Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 174157 |
| 354 Warren Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 168202 |
| 175 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 165169 |
| 182 Casey Cheese Factory Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 162921 |
| 218 Balcom Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 162921 |
| 233 Casey Cheese Factory Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 159551 |
| 635 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 159438 |
| 191 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 158989 |
| 148 Sears Pond Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 156180 |
| 306 Bell Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 156180 |
| 159 Davis Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 151685 |
| 226 Mordas Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 151685 |
| 323 Bell Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 151685 |
| 435 Casey Cheese Factory Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 150225 |
| 148 Davis Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 149775 |
| 302 Balcom Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 149551 |
| 111 Adams Rd, Columbus, NY 13485 | 148202 |
| 702 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 147865 |
| 442 Casey Cheese Factory Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 147191 |
| 215 Kelley Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 141798 |
| 318 Holdredge Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 140449 |
| 924 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13485 | 140449 |
| 227 Norton Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 135955 |
| 173 Fusch Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 134831 |
| 235 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 133708 |
| 348 Casey Cheese Factory Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 131798 |
| 353 Norton Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 131124 |
| 282 Bell Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 130562 |
| 164 Casey Cheese Factory Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 129213 |
| 530 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 129213 |
| 123 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 126067 |
| 267 Mordas Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 125618 |
| 430 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 122022 |
| 597 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 121348 |
| 185 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 119101 |
| 274 Fusch Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 117978 |
| 345 Kelley Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 115169 |
| 912 New Turnpike Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 112921 |
| 378 S Brookfield Rd, Columbus, NY 13485 | 112697 |
| 206 Hemlock Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 112360 |
| 261 Barnard Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 112360 |
| 775 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 111798 |
| 432 Norton Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 111236 |
| 295 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 110674 |
| 406 Pope Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 107079 |
| 184 Button Rd, Columbus, NY 13485 | 106742 |
| 517 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 105955 |
| 451 Pope Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 105843 |
| 298 Bell Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 105281 |
| 291 Balcom Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 104831 |
| 260 Holdredge Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 103034 |
| 226 Sears Pond Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 102921 |
| 188 Casey Cheese Factory Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 101124 |
| 863 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 100225 |
| 196 Davis Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 100000 |
| 268 Mordas Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 97079 |
| 398 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 95506 |
| 1118 New Turnpike Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 95393 |
| 233 Barnard Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 94382 |
| 112 Button Rd, Columbus, NY 13485 | 92697 |
| 109 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 91685 |
| 227 Mordas Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 91011 |
| 277 Barnard Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 90899 |
| 168 Walt Phillips Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 90787 |
| 119 Walt Phillips Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 88764 |
| 162 Winton Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 88090 |
| 468 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 87753 |
| 205 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 86742 |
| 113 Whitton Rd, Columbus, NY 13485 | 85618 |
| 123 Whitton Rd, Columbus, NY 13485 | 84494 |
| 148 Mary Perkins Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 84270 |
| 376 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 82247 |
| 843 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 82247 |
| 169 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 78090 |
| 311 Fusch Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 76404 |
| 202 S Brookfield Rd, Columbus, NY 13485 | 76292 |
| 113 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 75393 |
| 152 Holdredge Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 73034 |
| 386 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 73034 |
| 188 Kelley Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 67416 |
| 314 Walt Phillips Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 67416 |
| 130 Walt Phillips Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 65281 |
| 162 Barnard Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 63708 |
| 426 Holdredge Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 61236 |
| 115 Rock Calhoun Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 61011 |
| 162 Sears Pond Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 60337 |
| 251 Barnard Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 56854 |
| 247 Bell Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 55056 |
| 136 Barnard Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 54157 |
| 176 Button Rd, Columbus, NY 13485 | 50000 |
| 887 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 50000 |
| 219 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 48315 |
| 649 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 46966 |
| 169 Barnard Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 46292 |
| 124 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 44944 |
| 396 S Brookfield Rd, Columbus, NY 13485 | 43820 |
| 129 Fusch Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 42247 |
| 264 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 41348 |
| 110 Loomis Ln, Columbus, NY 13460 | 38539 |
| 879 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 37865 |
| 112 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 34045 |
| 116 Loomis Ln, Columbus, NY 13460 | 33708 |
| 956 New Turnpike Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 32584 |
| 151 Spurr St, Columbus, NY 13411 | 32360 |
| 109 Church Ln, Columbus, NY 13460 | 31348 |
| 117 Whitton Rd, Columbus, NY 13485 | 31348 |
| 121 Loomis Ln, Columbus, NY 13460 | 30899 |
| 214 Pope Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 28090 |
| 382 Casey Cheese Factory Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 26292 |
| 240 Barnard Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 25618 |
| 319 S Brookfield Rd, Columbus, NY 13485 | 22472 |
| 492 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 21798 |
| 103 Loomis Ln, Columbus, NY 13460 | 19663 |
| 288 Holdredge Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 19663 |
| 174 Kelley Rd, Columbus, NY 13411 | 18090 |
| 267 Casey Cheese Factory Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 16966 |
| 464 Columbus Hill Rd, Columbus, NY 13460 | 3483 |