Milton, NY - Most Valuable Residential Properties in 2024
Updated on November 21, 2025.
According to data from official New York government agencies, among residential properties in Milton, NY, the following were the most valuable residential properties by Market Value in 2024. The most valuable residential property was 1062 Rock City Rd ($1.47M), followed by 1 Catalina Dr ($1.33M), 53 Heisler Rd ($1.27M), and 1128 Middle Line Rd ($1.19M).
The chart below shows the top 10 valuable residential properties, and the table below shows the top 200.
You can see similar information for other New York cities.
You may also be interested in:
Data Source: Official Government Sites.
Milton, NY - Most Valuable Residential Properties in 2024
Items per page:
25
0 of 0
| Address | Market Value ($) |
|---|---|
| 1062 Rock City Rd, Milton, NY 12863 | 1468254 |
| 1 Catalina Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 1331429 |
| 53 Heisler Rd, Milton, NY 12863 | 1269841 |
| 1128 Middle Line Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 1190476 |
| 575 Rowland St, Milton, NY 12866 | 1046032 |
| 8 Magnolia Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 1031587 |
| 5 Catalina Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 1026984 |
| 38 Catalina Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 992063 |
| 35 Catalina Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 975873 |
| 1139 Middle Line Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 975397 |
| 1028 Rock City Rd, Milton, NY 12863 | 960317 |
| 11 Magnolia Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 952381 |
| 839 Greenwood Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 944444 |
| 36 Catalina Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 929365 |
| 1155 Middle Line Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 912698 |
| 8 Catalina Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 912698 |
| 911 Thomas Way, Milton, NY 12850 | 912698 |
| 17 Catalina Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 896825 |
| 1 Constitution Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 877302 |
| 32 River Rock Dr, Milton, NY 12863 | 873810 |
| 228 Maple Ave, Milton, NY 12020 | 873016 |
| 30 Pleasant St, Milton, NY 12020 | 873016 |
| 10 Jennifer Ln, Milton, NY 12020 | 868214 |
| 13 Creekside Dr, Milton, NY 12863 | 865397 |
| 1167 Middle Line Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 841270 |
| 82 Greenfield Ave, Milton, NY 12020 | 841270 |
| 939 Rock City Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 841270 |
| 254 Stone Church Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 836508 |
| 359 Le Roux Rd, Milton, NY 12850 | 833333 |
| 531 Middle Line Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 833333 |
| 15 Berkshire Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 832032 |
| 14 Encore Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 825397 |
| 31 Catalina Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 825397 |
| 10 Magnolia Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 809524 |
| 10 Old Mill Ct, Milton, NY 12863 | 809524 |
| 8 Wiebicke Ct, Milton, NY 12866 | 809524 |
| 6 Magnolia Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 802032 |
| 353 Le Roux Rd, Milton, NY 12850 | 801587 |
| 15 Encore Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 794365 |
| 320 Jatski Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 793651 |
| 37 Creekside Dr, Milton, NY 12863 | 793651 |
| 6 Jennifer Ln, Milton, NY 12020 | 793651 |
| 76 Hoffman Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 793651 |
| 8 Jennifer Ln, Milton, NY 12020 | 793651 |
| 22 Encore Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 788889 |
| 18 Encore Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 778571 |
| 17 Encore Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 777778 |
| 24 Oakwood Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 777778 |
| 7 Encore Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 777778 |
| 868 Middle Line Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 777778 |
| 9 Magnolia Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 777778 |
| 20 Encore Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 770635 |
| 1 Wiebicke Ct, Milton, NY 12866 | 769841 |
| 7 Wiebicke Ct, Milton, NY 12866 | 769841 |
| 199 Stone Church Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 767937 |
| 15 Oakwood Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 761905 |
| 2 Magnolia Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 754762 |
| 7 Pinewood Ln, Milton, NY 12020 | 754762 |
| 13 River Rock Dr, Milton, NY 12863 | 753968 |
| 3226 Grenell Rd, Milton, NY 12850 | 753968 |
| 500 Sodeman Rd, Milton, NY 12850 | 753968 |
| 8 Encore Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 753968 |
| 11 Encore Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 747143 |
| 804 Middle Line Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 746032 |
| 10 Oakwood Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 738095 |
| 320 Saratoga Ave, Milton, NY 12020 | 738095 |
| 587 Middle Line Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 738095 |
| 662 Acland Blvd, Milton, NY 12020 | 738095 |
| 8 Arlington Cir, Milton, NY 12020 | 738095 |
| 13 Encore Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 737833 |
| 5 Encore Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 736508 |
| 25 Catalina Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 735714 |
| 33 Creekside Dr, Milton, NY 12863 | 735397 |
| 909 Murray Rd, Milton, NY 12850 | 731746 |
| 2006 Barrett Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 730159 |
| 29 Catalina Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 728571 |
| 3234 Grenell Rd, Milton, NY 12850 | 728571 |
| 10 Arlington Cir, Milton, NY 12020 | 722222 |
| 9 Creek View Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 722222 |
| 924 MacArthur Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 722222 |
| 932 MacArthur Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 722222 |
| 934 MacArthur Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 722222 |
| 53 Creekside Dr, Milton, NY 12863 | 721190 |
| 8 Benedict Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 720635 |
| 3 King James Ct, Milton, NY 12866 | 716190 |
| 13 Catalina Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 714286 |
| 14 Oakwood Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 714286 |
| 5 Constitution Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 714286 |
| 970 MacArthur Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 714286 |
| 378 Finley Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 711270 |
| 881 Murray Rd, Milton, NY 12850 | 707619 |
| 664 Acland Blvd, Milton, NY 12020 | 706349 |
| 46 Hoffman Rd, Milton, NY 12866 | 705238 |
| 58 Huntington Way, Milton, NY 12020 | 704444 |
| 4 Arlington Cir, Milton, NY 12020 | 699206 |
| 4 Magnolia Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 698413 |
| 1120 Middle Line Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 693651 |
| 17 Wyndham Way, Milton, NY 12020 | 691270 |
| 9 Catalina Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 691270 |
| 1093 Middle Line Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 690476 |
| 2020 Barrett Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 690476 |
| 7 Benedict Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 690476 |
| 730 Geyser Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 690476 |
| 25 Oakwood Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 682540 |
| 5 Wiebicke Ct, Milton, NY 12866 | 682540 |
| 609 Acland Blvd, Milton, NY 12020 | 682540 |
| 915 MacArthur Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 680159 |
| 17 Paisley Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 679365 |
| 658 Acland Blvd, Milton, NY 12020 | 678095 |
| 270 Stone Church Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 674603 |
| 52 Hoffman Rd, Milton, NY 12866 | 674603 |
| 562 Sherman Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 674603 |
| 7 Catalina Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 674603 |
| 29 Creekside Dr, Milton, NY 12863 | 667857 |
| 27 Creekside Dr, Milton, NY 12863 | 666667 |
| 959 MacArthur Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 666667 |
| 3530 Galway Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 663968 |
| 3535 Galway Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 663492 |
| 336 Jatski Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 660357 |
| 10 Catalina Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 658730 |
| 360 Le Roux Rd, Milton, NY 12850 | 658730 |
| 47 Hoffman Rd, Milton, NY 12866 | 658730 |
| 65 Hoffman Rd, Milton, NY 12866 | 658730 |
| 7 Oakwood Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 658730 |
| 7 Paisley Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 658730 |
| 906 MacArthur Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 658730 |
| 16 Oakwood Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 657143 |
| 968 MacArthur Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 651905 |
| 21 Wyndham Way, Milton, NY 12020 | 650794 |
| 28 River Rock Dr, Milton, NY 12863 | 650794 |
| 343 Finley Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 650794 |
| 849 Rock City Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 650794 |
| 972 MacArthur Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 650794 |
| 31 Huntington Way, Milton, NY 12020 | 647619 |
| 533 Middle Line Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 646865 |
| 148 White Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 642857 |
| 316 Jatski Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 642857 |
| 608 Grand Ave, Milton, NY 12020 | 642857 |
| 54 Huntington Way, Milton, NY 12020 | 642381 |
| 40 Aldrich Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 642063 |
| 862 Salem Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 635635 |
| 6 Huntington Way, Milton, NY 12020 | 635079 |
| 14 Wyndham Way, Milton, NY 12020 | 634921 |
| 2 Wiebicke Ct, Milton, NY 12866 | 634921 |
| 2003 Barrett Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 634921 |
| 21 Oakwood Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 634921 |
| 60 Huntington Way, Milton, NY 12020 | 634921 |
| 656 Acland Blvd, Milton, NY 12020 | 634921 |
| 663 Rock City Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 634921 |
| 708 Rock City Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 634921 |
| 830 Murray Rd, Milton, NY 12850 | 634921 |
| 665 Acland Blvd, Milton, NY 12020 | 630317 |
| 451 Stone Church Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 629365 |
| 657 Acland Blvd, Milton, NY 12020 | 628571 |
| 12 Huntington Way, Milton, NY 12020 | 628095 |
| 124 Citation Way, Milton, NY 12020 | 627857 |
| 37 Aldrich Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 627778 |
| 26 Oakwood Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 626984 |
| 5 Cobble Hill Ct, Milton, NY 12863 | 626984 |
| 545 Rowland St, Milton, NY 12020 | 626984 |
| 9 Benedict Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 626984 |
| 9 Oakwood Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 626984 |
| 902 MacArthur Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 626984 |
| 958 MacArthur Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 626984 |
| 963 MacArthur Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 626984 |
| 3 Benedict Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 623810 |
| 103 Stockbridge Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 622540 |
| 912 MacArthur Dr, Milton, NY 12866 | 621333 |
| 706 Rock City Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 620000 |
| 101 Citation Way, Milton, NY 12020 | 619048 |
| 20 Oakwood Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 619048 |
| 525 Plummer Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 619048 |
| 549 Rowland St, Milton, NY 12020 | 619048 |
| 702 Rock City Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 619048 |
| 740 Geyser Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 619048 |
| 935 MacArthur Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 619048 |
| 938 MacArthur Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 619048 |
| 946 MacArthur Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 619048 |
| 6 Benedict Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 618730 |
| 207 Oak Ln, Milton, NY 12020 | 617619 |
| 77 Pleasant St, Milton, NY 12020 | 617460 |
| 97 Pleasant St, Milton, NY 12020 | 617460 |
| 140 Finley Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 617127 |
| 6 Wiebicke Ct, Milton, NY 12866 | 615873 |
| 955 MacArthur Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 614286 |
| 10 Old Glory Ln, Milton, NY 12020 | 613968 |
| 475 Sodeman Rd, Milton, NY 12850 | 613333 |
| 51 Hoffman Rd, Milton, NY 12866 | 613333 |
| 651 Acland Blvd, Milton, NY 12020 | 613175 |
| 944 MacArthur Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 612698 |
| 44 Huntington Way, Milton, NY 12020 | 612222 |
| 526 Plummer Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 611111 |
| 586 Acland Blvd, Milton, NY 12020 | 611111 |
| 6 Catalina Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 611111 |
| 923 MacArthur Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 611111 |
| 962 MacArthur Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 611111 |
| 208 Oak Ln, Milton, NY 12020 | 610159 |
| 924 Goode Rd, Milton, NY 12020 | 610159 |
| 11 Catalina Dr, Milton, NY 12020 | 607143 |
| 220 Falsetto Ct, Milton, NY 12020 | 606349 |