New Baltimore, NY - Most Valuable Residential Properties in 2024
Updated on November 21, 2025.
According to data from official New York government agencies, among residential properties in New Baltimore, NY, the following were the most valuable residential properties by Market Value in 2024. The most valuable residential property was 557 Highmount Rd ($1.40M), followed by 423 Highmount Rd ($1.37M), 1315 Mount Misery Rd ($1.35M), and 353 Haas Hill Rd ($1.30M).
The chart below shows the top 10 valuable residential properties, and the table below shows the top 200.
You can see similar information for other New York cities.
You may also be interested in:
Data Source: Official Government Sites.
New Baltimore, NY - Most Valuable Residential Properties in 2024
Items per page:
25
0 of 0
| Address | Market Value ($) |
|---|---|
| 557 Highmount Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 1402439 |
| 423 Highmount Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 1368293 |
| 1315 Mount Misery Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 1353659 |
| 353 Haas Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 1297561 |
| 112 Middle Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 1048780 |
| 51 Meadow Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 992683 |
| 96 Mirror Lake Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12042 | 975610 |
| 933 Medway Earlton Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12058 | 901951 |
| 238 Paradise Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12051 | 886341 |
| 138 Lydon Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 878049 |
| 52 Hillcrest Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 846341 |
| 1776 River Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 844634 |
| 15 Old Stonewall Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 839024 |
| 523 Lime Kiln Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 829268 |
| 1047 Medway Earlton Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12058 | 827561 |
| 21 Horton Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 817073 |
| 382 Highmount Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 817073 |
| 147 School Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 798780 |
| 354 Main St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 792683 |
| 89 Scheller Park Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 789512 |
| 39 Jesse Ann Cir, New Baltimore, NY 12058 | 785122 |
| 369 Highmount Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 781463 |
| 368 School Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 756098 |
| 105 Matthews Point Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 752195 |
| 122 Willowbrook Dr, New Baltimore, NY 12176 | 731707 |
| 1530 River Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 712195 |
| 1838 River Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 707805 |
| 380 Main St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 702439 |
| 212 Matthews Point Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 700244 |
| 38 Deans Mill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 697561 |
| 80 Mill St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 680732 |
| 71 School Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 672195 |
| 22 Mill St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 670732 |
| 52 Hadley Dr, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 670732 |
| 98 Highbridge Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 663415 |
| 320 Main St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 658537 |
| 12 Mill St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 656098 |
| 336 Main St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 655610 |
| 223 Deans Mill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 653659 |
| 1474 Aquetuck Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12143 | 641463 |
| 57 Sweezey Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 636585 |
| 41 New St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 630976 |
| 188 Scheller Park Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 629268 |
| 392 River Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 626829 |
| 56 Mill St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 626098 |
| 118 School Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 621951 |
| 40 Madison Ave, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 619512 |
| 64 Matthews Point Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 618780 |
| 55 Horton Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 615366 |
| 439 Shady Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12046 | 607317 |
| 426 Hillcrest Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 604878 |
| 96 School Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 602439 |
| 369 Main St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 597561 |
| 98 Old Stonewall Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 597561 |
| 215 Highmount Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 597317 |
| 275 Dugway Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 593902 |
| 305 School Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 590244 |
| 802 Roberts Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 585366 |
| 1378 Honey Hollow Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12042 | 563902 |
| 77 Hillcrest Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 563415 |
| 526 Roberts Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 562683 |
| 314 Main St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 562439 |
| 1436 Aquetuck Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12143 | 560976 |
| 1439 Aquetuck Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12143 | 560976 |
| 1780 River Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 560976 |
| 40 Lydon Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 560976 |
| 164 Madison Ave, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 560244 |
| 944 River Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 558049 |
| 1078 Gedney Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12046 | 553659 |
| 270 Alcove Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 553659 |
| 344 School Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 550244 |
| 178 Scheller Park Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 548780 |
| 32 Mill St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 548780 |
| 1116 Mount Misery Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 548537 |
| 75 Wyche Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 547561 |
| 1878 River Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 543268 |
| 275 School Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 541707 |
| 370 Main St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 534634 |
| 498 Shady Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12046 | 532927 |
| 991 Deans Mill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12143 | 532683 |
| 174 Hillcrest Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 530488 |
| 23 Staco Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 530488 |
| 50 Liberty St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 527317 |
| 737 Highmount Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 526341 |
| 400 Highmount Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 524390 |
| 491 Highmount Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 524390 |
| 510 High Rock Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 524146 |
| 1095 Aquetuck Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12143 | 512195 |
| 125 Independence Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 512195 |
| 36 Madison Ave, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 506098 |
| 125 Cole Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 504878 |
| 651 Honey Hollow Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12058 | 504878 |
| 309 Shady Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 503659 |
| 180 Main St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 500000 |
| 24 Sunset Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 500000 |
| 802 Deans Mill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12143 | 500000 |
| 711 Roberts Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 498780 |
| 1018 Deans Mill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12143 | 497073 |
| 91 Madison Ave, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 497073 |
| 351 Jennings Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 494878 |
| 1014 River Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 494390 |
| 311 School Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 492683 |
| 49 Old Stonewall Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 492683 |
| 1303 River Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 491220 |
| 147 Old Field Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12042 | 489756 |
| 14 Silver Lake Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12042 | 488049 |
| 213 Sunset Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 488049 |
| 728 Honey Hollow Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12058 | 488049 |
| 147 Featherbed Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 487805 |
| 478 High Rock Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 487805 |
| 114 Highbridge Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 485854 |
| 406 Main St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 485854 |
| 168 Alcove Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 483902 |
| 27 Old Field Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12042 | 483902 |
| 27 New St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 481463 |
| 15 Sarles Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 480732 |
| 1410 River Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 479024 |
| 242 High Rock Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 477561 |
| 72 Kliese Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 475610 |
| 612 River Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 475366 |
| 310 Main St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 474878 |
| 604 River Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 470732 |
| 1945 River Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 470000 |
| 119 Hillcrest Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 465122 |
| 66 Old Kings Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 464390 |
| 1089 Alcove Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 463415 |
| 1250 Honey Hollow Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12042 | 463415 |
| 1378 River Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 463415 |
| 153 Pine Grove Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 463415 |
| 36 Silver Lake Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12042 | 463415 |
| 432 Sodom Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 463415 |
| 517 High Rock Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 463415 |
| 33 Middle Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 462683 |
| 37 Meadow Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 462439 |
| 49 Paradise Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12051 | 462439 |
| 186 Scheller Park Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 460976 |
| 176 High Rock Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 460488 |
| 34 Guy Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 460488 |
| 22 Valley View Dr, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 458293 |
| 214 Hillcrest Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 456341 |
| 321 Flatbush Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 453659 |
| 1669 River Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 452439 |
| 43 Horton Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 452195 |
| 22 Madison Ave, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 451220 |
| 945 Deans Mill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12143 | 451220 |
| 1013 Deans Mill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12143 | 450000 |
| 477 High Rock Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 449512 |
| 89 Main St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 448049 |
| 216 Highmount Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 446585 |
| 285 Staco Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 446341 |
| 570 Lime Kiln Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 445854 |
| 47 Cedar Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 445122 |
| 257 Scheller Park Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 443902 |
| 291 Kings Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 443902 |
| 1296 Aquetuck Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12143 | 443415 |
| 117 Jennings Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 442927 |
| 175 Flatbush Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 441463 |
| 54 School Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 440732 |
| 156 Main St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 439268 |
| 370 Highmount Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 439024 |
| 42 Mill St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 439024 |
| 144 Lydon Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 437073 |
| 330 Scheller Park Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 436585 |
| 86 Meadow Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 435122 |
| 91 Lydon Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 435122 |
| 539 Scheller Park Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 433415 |
| 1455 Aquetuck Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12143 | 431707 |
| 364 Main St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 430732 |
| 28 Kimwood Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 428537 |
| 838 Alcove Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 428537 |
| 626 High Rock Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 427805 |
| 564 Staco Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 426829 |
| 9 Kings Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 426829 |
| 1047 Deans Mill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12143 | 426585 |
| 138 Main St, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 422195 |
| 168 Pine Grove Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 421463 |
| 2263 River Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 421220 |
| 185 Beaver Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12058 | 420244 |
| 53 Nodine Mountain Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 420244 |
| 29 Lydon Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 419512 |
| 601 High Rock Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 418537 |
| 45 Washington Ave, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 418049 |
| 133 Cole Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 417805 |
| 76 Sylvendale Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12046 | 417561 |
| 1965 River Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 416012 |
| 1459 River Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 414634 |
| 408 Roberts Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 414634 |
| 44 Huckle Hill Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12143 | 414634 |
| 44 Kimwood Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 414634 |
| 47 Kreitmeier Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 414390 |
| 37 Huckle Hill Ln, New Baltimore, NY 12143 | 413902 |
| 383 Haas Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 413902 |
| 401 Sodom Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 412195 |
| 80 Middle Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 412195 |
| 1041 Roberts Hill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 409024 |
| 1994 River Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 408537 |
| 662 Deans Mill Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 408537 |
| 1154 River Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 407317 |
| 681 High Rock Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12087 | 407317 |
| 1993 River Rd, New Baltimore, NY 12192 | 406341 |