Plymouth, NY - Most Valuable Residential Properties in 2024
Updated on November 21, 2025.
According to data from official New York government agencies, among residential properties in Plymouth, NY, the following were the most valuable residential properties by Market Value in 2024. The most valuable residential property was 235 Daniels Rd ($543.50K), followed by 1551 Reservoir Hill Rd ($528.33K), 397 Doing Rd ($424.23K), and 312 Tinker Ridge Rd ($413.84K).
The chart below shows the top 10 valuable residential properties, and the table below shows the top 200.
You can see similar information for other New York cities.
You may also be interested in:
Data Source: Official Government Sites.
Plymouth, NY - Most Valuable Residential Properties in 2024
Items per page:
25
0 of 0
| Address | Market Value ($) |
|---|---|
| 235 Daniels Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 543495 |
| 1551 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 528329 |
| 397 Doing Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 424225 |
| 312 Tinker Ridge Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 413835 |
| 1408 Center Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 407152 |
| 178 Elmer Harris Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 398133 |
| 179 Cottage Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 346427 |
| 156 Elmer Harris Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 330966 |
| 112 Linda Ln, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 329698 |
| 227 South Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 322090 |
| 368 Pike Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13832 | 322090 |
| 105 Country Club Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 317017 |
| 198 Elmer Harris Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 317017 |
| 323 Jackson Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 317017 |
| 293 Inman Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 306873 |
| 715 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 305605 |
| 269 Montgomery Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 303383 |
| 274 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 299970 |
| 290 Pike Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 299265 |
| 105 Canasawacta Ter, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 291656 |
| 132 Country Club Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 291656 |
| 146 Canasawacta Ter, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 291656 |
| 1349 Center Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 286919 |
| 263 Pike Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 278975 |
| 281 Morley Rd, Plymouth, NY 13832 | 272777 |
| 127 Country Club Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 268831 |
| 1421 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 268831 |
| 149 Canasawacta Ter, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 263759 |
| 560 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 263759 |
| 321 Inman Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 261222 |
| 144 Elmer Harris Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 260051 |
| 253 Montgomery Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 259777 |
| 120 Country Club Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 258686 |
| 260 Cook House Rd, Plymouth, NY 13832 | 258686 |
| 255 South Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 256150 |
| 129 Serafen Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 253614 |
| 1416 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 253614 |
| 200 Elmer Harris Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 253614 |
| 416 Inman Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 253614 |
| 296 Cook House Rd, Plymouth, NY 13832 | 252346 |
| 148 Collier Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 249011 |
| 109 Cottage Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 248542 |
| 142 Ashcraft Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 248542 |
| 431 Doing Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 248542 |
| 431 Sherburne Four Corners Rd, Plymouth, NY 13464 | 248542 |
| 133 Country Club Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 243469 |
| 154 Canasawacta Ter, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 240933 |
| 515 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 239336 |
| 152 Canasawacta Ter, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 238397 |
| 678 Tinker Ridge Rd, Plymouth, NY 13464 | 238397 |
| 481 Doing Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 237129 |
| 127 Stevens Crst, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 235861 |
| 490 Inman Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 235861 |
| 173 Porter Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 232392 |
| 216 Pigeon Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 232209 |
| 212 Canasawacta Ter, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 230789 |
| 510 Inman Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 230789 |
| 139 Cottage Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 228253 |
| 262 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 228253 |
| 276 Elmer Harris Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 228253 |
| 137 Montgomery Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 227532 |
| 462 Inman Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 226350 |
| 216 Jackson Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 225716 |
| 188 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 223688 |
| 374 Ashcraft Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 223434 |
| 502 Inman Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 223180 |
| 402 Pigeon Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 221912 |
| 446 Tinker Ridge Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 221659 |
| 670 German Hollow Rd, Plymouth, NY 13464 | 221060 |
| 448 Inman Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 220644 |
| 656 Tinker Ridge Rd, Plymouth, NY 13464 | 216422 |
| 194 Elmer Harris Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 215572 |
| 113 Adams Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 213036 |
| 138 Pierce Rd, Plymouth, NY 13832 | 211768 |
| 179 Tinker Ridge Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 210500 |
| 470 Inman Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 208937 |
| 133 Cottage Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 207963 |
| 141 Country Club Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 207963 |
| 158 Canasawacta Ter, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 207963 |
| 138 Pike Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 207837 |
| 381 Inman Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 206695 |
| 112 Country Club Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 204593 |
| 128 Canasawacta Ter, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 202891 |
| 138 Cook House Rd, Plymouth, NY 13832 | 202891 |
| 271 Sherburne Four Corners Rd, Plymouth, NY 13464 | 202891 |
| 813 Cook House Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 202891 |
| 825 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 202891 |
| 169 Brookrun Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 201045 |
| 116 Stevens Crst, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 200355 |
| 141 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 197819 |
| 212 Cottage Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 197819 |
| 439 Sherburne Four Corners Rd, Plymouth, NY 13464 | 197819 |
| 124 Stevens Crst, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 195283 |
| 188 Canasawacta Ter, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 195283 |
| 137 Jackson Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 194268 |
| 111 Highland Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 192747 |
| 113 Canasawacta Ter, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 192747 |
| 149 Cottage Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 192747 |
| 164 Elmer Harris Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 190210 |
| 836 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 190210 |
| 433 Inman Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 188942 |
| 185 Cottage Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 187674 |
| 167 Cook House Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 184885 |
| 417 German Hollow Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 183870 |
| 143 Canasawacta Ter, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 182602 |
| 174 South Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 182602 |
| 241 North Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 182602 |
| 301 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 182602 |
| 725 Doing Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 180066 |
| 255 Morley Rd, Plymouth, NY 13832 | 179305 |
| 206 Elmer Harris Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 178798 |
| 244 Ashcraft Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 178798 |
| 117 Canasawacta Ter, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 177530 |
| 295 Adams Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 177530 |
| 370 Doing Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 177530 |
| 495 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 177200 |
| 186 Pierce Rd, Plymouth, NY 13832 | 176769 |
| 467 Doing Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 176262 |
| 299 Sherburne Four Corners Rd, Plymouth, NY 13464 | 176236 |
| 139 Canasawacta Ter, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 175755 |
| 261 Tinker Ridge Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 174448 |
| 109 Canasawacta Ter, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 173561 |
| 268 Elmer Harris Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 172458 |
| 178 German Hollow Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 169921 |
| 503 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 169921 |
| 752 Doing Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 169921 |
| 324 Ashcraft Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 168653 |
| 126 Linda Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 165293 |
| 154 Cook House Rd, Plymouth, NY 13832 | 164849 |
| 752 Cook House Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 164849 |
| 114 Canasawacta Ter, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 162313 |
| 121 Pike Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 162313 |
| 1412 Center Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 162313 |
| 167 Liddle Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 162313 |
| 188 Morley Rd, Plymouth, NY 13832 | 162313 |
| 228 German Hollow Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 162313 |
| 108 Underwood Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 160538 |
| 112 Ashcraft Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 160538 |
| 103 Cottage Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 159777 |
| 148 Liddle Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 159777 |
| 160 Moon Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 158509 |
| 1286 Center Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 157996 |
| 137 Cole Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 157241 |
| 138 Underwood Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 157241 |
| 148 Moon Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 157241 |
| 164 Underwood Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 157241 |
| 329 Pike Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13832 | 155973 |
| 115 Montgomery Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 154324 |
| 230 Elmer Harris Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 153944 |
| 118 Santana Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 152168 |
| 127 Cottage Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 152168 |
| 147 Cottage Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 152168 |
| 473 Doing Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 152168 |
| 107 Cottage Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 149632 |
| 162 Collier Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 149632 |
| 437 Ashcraft Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 149379 |
| 104 Ashcraft Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 147096 |
| 106 Canasawacta Ter, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 147096 |
| 128 Starview Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 147096 |
| 226 Pike Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 147096 |
| 403 Ashcraft Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 147096 |
| 194 North Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 146082 |
| 1237 Center Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 145881 |
| 181 Pigeon Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 145828 |
| 443 Inman Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 143799 |
| 1332 Center Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 142024 |
| 269 Pigeon Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 142024 |
| 416 Pigeon Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 140898 |
| 211 Cottage Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 140756 |
| 376 Pigeon Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 140756 |
| 138 Countryside Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 139488 |
| 169 Cottage Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 139488 |
| 205 Cottage Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 139488 |
| 220 Montgomery Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 139488 |
| 782 Cook House Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 139488 |
| 816 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 139488 |
| 824 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 139488 |
| 107 South Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 139153 |
| 348 German Hollow Rd, Plymouth, NY 13464 | 137459 |
| 273 Morley Rd, Plymouth, NY 13832 | 136952 |
| 284 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 136952 |
| 361 Pigeon Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 136952 |
| 510 Tinker Ridge Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 136952 |
| 147 Daniels Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 136622 |
| 172 Cook House Rd, Plymouth, NY 13832 | 134162 |
| 298 Chan Aldrich Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 133870 |
| 464 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 132343 |
| 230 Inman Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 132290 |
| 132 Morley Rd, Plymouth, NY 13832 | 131879 |
| 200 Ashcraft Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 131879 |
| 302 Pigeon Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 131879 |
| 549 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 131879 |
| 110 Highland Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 129921 |
| 180 Pike Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 129343 |
| 218 Blackman Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 129343 |
| 740 Doing Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 128836 |
| 140 Cottage Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 128075 |
| 108 Jaremko Ln, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 126807 |
| 1361 Reservoir Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13815 | 126807 |
| 144 Cole Hill Rd, Plymouth, NY 13844 | 126807 |