Smithfield, NY - Most Valuable Residential Properties in 2024
Updated on November 21, 2025.
According to data from official New York government agencies, among residential properties in Smithfield, NY, the following were the most valuable residential properties by Market Value in 2024. The most valuable residential property was 5027 Swamp School Rd ($531.25K), followed by 5738 Old County Rd ($523.44K), 5503 Northrup Rd ($515.63K), and 5251 Fearon Rd ($510.94K).
The chart below shows the top 10 valuable residential properties, and the table below shows the top 200.
You can see similar information for other New York cities.
You may also be interested in:
Data Source: Official Government Sites.
Smithfield, NY - Most Valuable Residential Properties in 2024
Items per page:
25
0 of 0
| Address | Market Value ($) |
|---|---|
| 5027 Swamp School Rd, Smithfield, NY 13035 | 531250 |
| 5738 Old County Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 523438 |
| 5503 Northrup Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 515625 |
| 5251 Fearon Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 510938 |
| 5171 Glass Factory Rd, Smithfield, NY 13409 | 501406 |
| 4560 Brooks Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 414063 |
| 5533 Glass Factory Rd, Smithfield, NY 13409 | 399063 |
| 5704 Northrup Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 392031 |
| 4198 Hoffman Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 390625 |
| 4795 Goff Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 390625 |
| 5867 Peterboro Rd, Smithfield, NY 13421 | 390625 |
| 5069 Williams Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 371094 |
| 5137 Glass Factory Rd, Smithfield, NY 13409 | 349219 |
| 4637 Brooks Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 342969 |
| 4651 Pleasant Valley Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 340625 |
| 4595 May Rd, Smithfield, NY 13409 | 329063 |
| 5029 Swamp Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 328125 |
| 5075 Peterboro Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 325781 |
| 4297 Cody Rd, Smithfield, NY 13035 | 321875 |
| 4526 Cody Rd, Smithfield, NY 13035 | 320313 |
| 5478 Williams Rd, Smithfield, NY 13409 | 320313 |
| 5409 Buyea Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 312500 |
| 4475 Old County Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 308438 |
| 5183 Glass Factory Rd, Smithfield, NY 13409 | 304688 |
| 5313 Peterboro Rd, Smithfield, NY 13421 | 303281 |
| 4881 Goff Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 299688 |
| 4798 Goff Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 286719 |
| 5449 Williams Rd, Smithfield, NY 13409 | 281563 |
| 4493 Johnson Rd, Smithfield, NY 13409 | 275781 |
| 4343 Pleasant Valley Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 268750 |
| 5500 Northrup Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 268125 |
| 5481 Old County Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 262969 |
| 5848 Oxbow Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 262344 |
| 5733 Old County Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 262031 |
| 5090 Swamp Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 261875 |
| 5372 Oxbow Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 261563 |
| 5094 Fearon Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 258125 |
| 4664 Park St, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 257813 |
| 6125 Old County Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 257813 |
| 4576 May Rd, Smithfield, NY 13409 | 257344 |
| 4621 Rich Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 253594 |
| 5308 Glass Factory Rd, Smithfield, NY 13409 | 253594 |
| 4500 Cody Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 251094 |
| 4690 Park St, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 250000 |
| 5555 Northrup Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 247500 |
| 4427 Cody Rd, Smithfield, NY 13035 | 246250 |
| 5391 Peterboro Rd, Smithfield, NY 13421 | 246094 |
| 5188 Fearon Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 245156 |
| 6225 Old County Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 244844 |
| 5262 Buyea Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 244531 |
| 5322 Oxbow Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 244063 |
| 4799 Gill Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 243906 |
| 5872 Creek Rd, Smithfield, NY 13421 | 242813 |
| 5089 Swamp School Rd, Smithfield, NY 13035 | 241719 |
| 4747 Rich Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 239063 |
| 5109 Buyea Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 237500 |
| 5157 Fearon Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 237188 |
| 4741 Peterboro Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 234375 |
| 4780 Glass Factory Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 234063 |
| 5503 Buyea Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 233594 |
| 4886 Goff Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 232813 |
| 4935 Goff Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 232500 |
| 5433 Williams Rd, Smithfield, NY 13409 | 232188 |
| 4517 Brooks Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 228281 |
| 4615 Pleasant Valley Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 228125 |
| 5504 Northrup Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 228125 |
| 4515 Roher Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 227344 |
| 4811 Gill Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 226563 |
| 5017 Peterboro Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 226563 |
| 5651 Buyea Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 222969 |
| 5145 Buyea Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 222656 |
| 4419 Johnson Rd, Smithfield, NY 13409 | 222344 |
| 4909 Goff Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 218750 |
| 5547 Creek Rd, Smithfield, NY 13421 | 218594 |
| 5106 Glass Factory Rd, Smithfield, NY 13409 | 217969 |
| 5481 Buyea Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 217813 |
| 4876 Gill Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 217188 |
| 4866 Goff Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 215469 |
| 5142 Glass Factory Rd, Smithfield, NY 13409 | 211250 |
| 4702 Peterboro Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 207969 |
| 4641 Peterboro Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 207813 |
| 5035 Williams Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 206875 |
| 4494 Roher Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 205938 |
| 4478 Roher Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 205469 |
| 4539 Brooks Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 204375 |
| 4591 Peterboro Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 203906 |
| 4445 Davis Corners Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 203125 |
| 4694 Park St, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 203125 |
| 4756 Gill Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 202656 |
| 5324 Oxbow Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 202656 |
| 5313 Oxbow Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 198906 |
| 5472 Northrup Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 196875 |
| 5602 Creek Rd, Smithfield, NY 13421 | 196563 |
| 4555 Roher Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 195156 |
| 4493 Brooks Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 194219 |
| 5265 Pleasant Valley Rd, Smithfield, NY 13035 | 193750 |
| 5531 Creek Rd, Smithfield, NY 13421 | 193750 |
| 5287 Pleasant Valley Rd, Smithfield, NY 13035 | 192813 |
| 5381 Peterboro Rd, Smithfield, NY 13421 | 190469 |
| 4574 Brooks Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 190156 |
| 4820 Rich Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 189844 |
| 4365 Pleasant Valley Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 188906 |
| 4641 Glass Factory Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 188750 |
| 4505 Roher Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 187969 |
| 5522 Fearon Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 187656 |
| 5174 Pleasant Valley Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 187500 |
| 5409 Peterboro Rd, Smithfield, NY 13421 | 187500 |
| 4717 Pleasant Valley Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 182813 |
| 5586 Stockbridge Falls Rd, Smithfield, NY 13409 | 182656 |
| 4824 Goff Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 182031 |
| 5271 Pleasant Valley Rd, Smithfield, NY 13035 | 182031 |
| 4898 Old County Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 181094 |
| 4221 Bennett Rd, Smithfield, NY 13035 | 179688 |
| 4843 Old County Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 179688 |
| 5132 Swamp Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 178906 |
| 5697 Creek Rd, Smithfield, NY 13421 | 177813 |
| 5650 Old County Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 177188 |
| 4365 Davis Corners Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 176094 |
| 5030 Williams Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 175625 |
| 5395 Fearon Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 175313 |
| 5115 Williams Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 173750 |
| 5199 Peterboro Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 173438 |
| 5586 Old County Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 172188 |
| 4795 Peterboro Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 171875 |
| 4992 Pleasant Valley Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 171875 |
| 5183 Buyea Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 171875 |
| 5605 Fearon Rd, Smithfield, NY 13409 | 171875 |
| 5631 Creek Rd, Smithfield, NY 13421 | 171563 |
| 4395 Davis Corners Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 171250 |
| 5422 Buyea Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 171250 |
| 5928 Buyea Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 171250 |
| 4675 May Rd, Smithfield, NY 13409 | 170625 |
| 5425 Northrup Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 170000 |
| 4642 Glass Factory Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 169375 |
| 4441 Old County Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 168906 |
| 4526 Pleasant Valley Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 166875 |
| 5349 Fearon Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 166563 |
| 4997 Goff Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 165625 |
| 5844 Creek Rd, Smithfield, NY 13421 | 165469 |
| 4867 Goff Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 165313 |
| 5312 Buyea Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 164375 |
| 4335 Davis Corners Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 164219 |
| 6213 Old County Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 163125 |
| 4724 Gill Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 162969 |
| 5594 Stockbridge Falls Rd, Smithfield, NY 13409 | 161563 |
| 4344 Davis Corners Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 161094 |
| 4841 Goff Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 160625 |
| 4419 Davis Corners Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 159844 |
| 5017 Swamp Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 159219 |
| 5434 Creek Rd, Smithfield, NY 13421 | 158594 |
| 4839 Gill Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 157500 |
| 5217 Buyea Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 157188 |
| 5801 Oxbow Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 156719 |
| 5120 Glass Factory Rd, Smithfield, NY 13409 | 155781 |
| 5484 Fearon Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 154219 |
| 5035 Goff Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 153438 |
| 4568 Cody Rd, Smithfield, NY 13035 | 152969 |
| 5229 Williams Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 152500 |
| 5302 Buyea Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 151719 |
| 4742 Swamp Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 151563 |
| 5187 Fearon Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 151406 |
| 4901 Gill Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 151094 |
| 4682 Pleasant Valley Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 150000 |
| 6202 Old County Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 148438 |
| 5250 Pleasant Valley Rd, Smithfield, NY 13035 | 148281 |
| 4953 Goff Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 147813 |
| 4974 Gill Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 145625 |
| 5739 Peterboro Rd, Smithfield, NY 13421 | 145313 |
| 4835 Goff Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 144375 |
| 4733 Old County Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 144219 |
| 5763 Oxbow Rd, Smithfield, NY 13035 | 144219 |
| 5790 Creek Rd, Smithfield, NY 13421 | 144063 |
| 4675 Rich Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 143906 |
| 5137 Buyea Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 143906 |
| 5225 Fearon Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 143125 |
| 5112 Buyea Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 142656 |
| 5218 Swamp Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 142656 |
| 4544 Roher Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 141875 |
| 4755 Swamp Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 140625 |
| 4920 Old County Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 140625 |
| 5741 Oxbow Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 140313 |
| 5874 Buyea Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 140000 |
| 5289 Fearon Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 139844 |
| 5531 Williams Rd, Smithfield, NY 13409 | 139063 |
| 5357 Fearon Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 138750 |
| 5011 Goff Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 138281 |
| 5816 Oxbow Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 138281 |
| 4489 Brooks Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 137813 |
| 4617 Peterboro Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 137188 |
| 5173 Swamp Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 136875 |
| 5161 Glass Factory Rd, Smithfield, NY 13409 | 135938 |
| 5323 Oxbow Rd, Smithfield, NY 13032 | 135781 |
| 4619 Peterboro Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 135625 |
| 4236 Bennett Rd, Smithfield, NY 13035 | 134063 |
| 4598 Roher Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 133906 |
| 4597 Pleasant Valley Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 133281 |
| 5840 Peterboro Rd, Smithfield, NY 13421 | 133281 |
| 4375 Davis Corners Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 132813 |
| 4603 Peterboro Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 132813 |
| 5269 Fearon Rd, Smithfield, NY 13408 | 132813 |