5 Gardiner Way, Shelter Island, NY 11965 - Assessment Profile

Updated on November 23, 2025.

See below the recent assessment details for the residential property at 5 Gardiner Way, Shelter Island, NY 11965.

You can also see similar information for other residential properties in Shelter Island.

NB: If you want to know the owners of this property, contact us.

You may also be interested in:
Shelter Island, New York - Most Valuable Residential Properties in 2024

Data Source: Official Government Sources.

Property Information

Print Key Code

1.-2-6.1

Property Class

One Family Year-Round Residence

SWIS Code

473201

Tax Class

Roll Section

Grid Coordinates East

2455810

Grid Coordinates North

320535

Front Width (Feet)

110

School District

Shelter Island

Deed Book

12448

Page

717

Roll Year

2024

Market Value

$4,567,647

Assessment Land Value

$242,000

Assessment Total Value

$3,106,000

County Taxable Value

$3,106,000

Town Taxable Value

$3,106,000

School Taxable Value

$3,106,000