Zip Code: 06390 (Fishers Island, NY) - Trend of Average House Listing Price (Realtor)

Updated on February 16, 2026.

According to data from Realtor.com, the average house listing price for the 06390 Zip Code in January 2026 was $6,500,000. The month over month percentage change (MoM) was 0.0%, and the year over year percentage change (YoY) was 0.0833%.

You can see similar for other New York Zip Codes, and for New York.

The chart below shows the trend of the average house listing price in the 06390 zip code. The table below shows the trend of the average house listing price, and the MoM and YoY percentage changes.

Data Source: Realtor.
Zip Code: 06390 - Trend of Average House Listing Price ($)
Zip Code: 06390 Trend of Average House Listing Price
1 – 10 of 81
Month Price ($) MoM Perc. Change (%) YoY Perc. Change (%)
Aug 2016 2276333
Sep 2016 2276333
Oct 2016 1884800
Nov 2016 2261250
Dec 2016 1979375
Jan 2017 1697500
Feb 2017 1697500
Mar 2017 1697500
Apr 2017 1697500
Apr 2018 670000 -0.6053
May 2018 670000 0.0
Jun 2018 670000 0.0
Jul 2018 670000 0.0
Aug 2018 670000 0.0
Sep 2018 670000 0.0
Oct 2018 670000 0.0
Nov 2018 475000 -0.291
Dec 2018 475000 0.0
Jan 2019 475000 0.0
Feb 2019 475000 0.0
Mar 2019 475000 0.0
Apr 2019 787429 0.6577 0.1753
May 2019 1239083 0.5736 0.8494
Jun 2019 1260000 0.0169 0.8806
Jul 2019 1190000 -0.0556 0.7761
Aug 2019 1186429 -0.003 0.7708
Sep 2019 1155649 -0.0259 0.7248
Oct 2019 1130909 -0.0214 0.6879
Nov 2019 1111667 -0.017 1.3404
Dec 2019 1210000 0.0885 1.5474
Jan 2020 868750 -0.282 0.8289
Feb 2020 537500 -0.3813 0.1316
Mar 2020 1216667 1.2636 1.5614
Apr 2020 1180000 -0.0301 0.4985
May 2020 948000 -0.1966 -0.2349
Jun 2020 1097500 0.1577 -0.129
Jul 2020 1097500 0.0 -0.0777
Aug 2020 1097500 0.0 -0.075
Sep 2020 631667 -0.4244 -0.4534
Oct 2020 2600000 3.1161 1.299
Nov 2020 2600000 0.0 1.3388
Dec 2020 2600000 0.0 1.1488
Jan 2021 2600000 0.0 1.9928
Oct 2021 1700000 -0.3462
Nov 2021 1700000 0.0 -0.3462
Apr 2022 1450000
May 2022 1450000 0.0
May 2023 2700000 0.8621
Jun 2023 4087500 0.5139
Jul 2023 5475000 0.3394
Aug 2023 5475000 0.0
Sep 2023 5550000 0.0137
Oct 2023 6975000 0.2568
Nov 2023 6975000 0.0
Dec 2023 6912500 -0.009
Jan 2024 6912500 0.0
Feb 2024 5575000 -0.1935
Mar 2024 5575000 0.0
Apr 2024 5575000 0.0
May 2024 4062500 -0.2713 0.5046
Jun 2024 5385417 0.3256 0.3175
Jul 2024 6708333 0.2456 0.2253
Aug 2024 6243750 -0.0693 0.1404
Sep 2024 6243750 0.0 0.125
Oct 2024 4233333 -0.322 -0.3931
Nov 2024 4233333 0.0 -0.3931
Dec 2024 4233333 0.0 -0.3876
Jan 2025 3700000 -0.126 -0.4647
Feb 2025 6000000 0.6216 0.0762
Mar 2025 6000000 0.0 0.0762
Apr 2025 6000000 0.0 0.0762
May 2025 6000000 0.0 0.4769
Jun 2025 6000000 0.0 0.1141
Jul 2025 6800000 0.1333 0.0137
Aug 2025 6800000 0.0 0.0891
Sep 2025 6800000 0.0 0.0891
Oct 2025 6800000 0.0 0.6063
Nov 2025 5423750 -0.2024 0.2812
Dec 2025 6500000 0.1984 0.5354
Jan 2026 6500000 0.0 0.7568
Feb 2026 6500000 0.0 0.0833