Zip Code: 11964 (Shelter Island, NY) - Trend of Median House Listing Price Per Square Feet (Realtor)
Updated on March 13, 2026.

According to data from Realtor.com, the median house listing price per square feet for the 11964 Zip Code in February 2026 was $1,135. The month over month percentage change (MoM) was -0.0158%, and the year over year percentage change (YoY) was 0.1159%.

You can see similar for other New York Zip Codes, and for New York.

The chart below shows the trend of the median house listing price per square feet in the 11964 zip code. The table below shows the trend of the median house listing price per square feet, and the MoM and YoY percentage changes.

Data Source: Realtor.
Zip Code: 11964 - Trend of Median House Listing Price Per Square Feet ($)
Zip Code: 11964 Trend of Median House Listing Price Per Square Feet
Items per page:
1 – 10 of 116
Month Price ($) MoM Perc. Change (%) YoY Perc. Change (%)
Aug 2016 493
Sep 2016 514
Oct 2016 482
Nov 2016 515
Dec 2016 482
Jan 2017 478
Feb 2017 470
Mar 2017 471
Apr 2017 502
May 2017 475
Jun 2017 493
Jul 2017 550
Aug 2017 558 0.0154 0.1322
Sep 2017 558 -0.0002 0.0849
Oct 2017 558 0.0002 0.1568
Nov 2017 576 0.0323 0.1193
Dec 2017 582 0.0108 0.2086
Jan 2018 587 0.0082 0.229
Feb 2018 576 -0.0187 0.2266
Mar 2018 563 -0.022 0.1953
Apr 2018 584 0.0364 0.1641
May 2018 596 0.0214 0.2551
Jun 2018 695 0.1656 0.4113
Jul 2018 682 -0.0183 0.2415
Aug 2018 738 0.0817 0.3226
Sep 2018 741 0.0034 0.3274
Oct 2018 701 -0.0538 0.2558
Nov 2018 711 0.0146 0.2342
Dec 2018 712 0.0008 0.222
Jan 2019 738 0.0377 0.2578
Feb 2019 726 -0.0169 0.2601
Mar 2019 714 -0.0165 0.2672
Apr 2019 684 -0.0423 0.171
May 2019 691 0.0108 0.1589
Jun 2019 686 -0.0078 -0.0135
Jul 2019 703 0.0254 0.0305
Aug 2019 746 0.0611 0.0108
Sep 2019 746 0.0 0.0074
Oct 2019 746 -0.0009 0.0637
Nov 2019 729 -0.0226 0.0247
Dec 2019 716 -0.0176 0.0059
Jan 2020 754 0.0526 0.0204
Feb 2020 770 0.0221 0.0608
Mar 2020 772 0.0018 0.0806
Apr 2020 683 -0.1143 -0.0007
May 2020 680 -0.0043 -0.0155
Jun 2020 715 0.0503 0.0421
Jul 2020 753 0.0537 0.0708
Aug 2020 745 -0.0104 -0.0014
Sep 2020 767 0.0288 0.0274
Oct 2020 765 -0.0015 0.0267
Nov 2020 770 0.0064 0.0572
Dec 2020 773 0.003 0.0793
Jan 2021 774 0.0011 0.0265
Feb 2021 774 0.0006 0.0049
Mar 2021 800 0.0331 0.0363
Apr 2021 789 -0.0132 0.1545
May 2021 802 0.0165 0.1786
Jun 2021 799 -0.0042 0.1175
Jul 2021 794 -0.0052 0.0551
Aug 2021 818 0.0291 0.0973
Sep 2021 848 0.037 0.1061
Oct 2021 822 -0.0307 0.0738
Nov 2021 956 0.1627 0.2406
Dec 2021 841 -0.1202 0.0881
Jan 2022 906 0.0781 0.1719
Feb 2022 877 -0.0328 0.1328
Mar 2022 1203 0.3717 0.504
Apr 2022 1064 -0.1151 0.3487
May 2022 903 -0.1512 0.1263
Jun 2022 1072 0.1865 0.3419
Jul 2022 1046 -0.0237 0.3169
Aug 2022 989 -0.0543 0.2102
Sep 2022 920 -0.0705 0.0846
Oct 2022 948 0.031 0.1537
Nov 2022 948 0.0 -0.0078
Dec 2022 948 0.0 0.1278
Jan 2023 948 0.0 0.0461
Feb 2023 979 0.0329 0.1172
Mar 2023 994 0.0153 -0.1731
Apr 2023 950 -0.0447 -0.1072
May 2023 994 0.0467 0.101
Jun 2023 1002 0.0072 -0.0653
Jul 2023 994 -0.0072 -0.0495
Aug 2023 1002 0.0072 0.0123
Sep 2023 983 -0.0183 0.0692
Oct 2023 994 0.0113 0.0488
Nov 2023 1012 0.018 0.0676
Dec 2023 1104 0.0902 0.1639
Jan 2024 1097 -0.0057 0.1573
Feb 2024 1098 0.0008 0.1212
Mar 2024 1112 0.0122 0.1178
Apr 2024 1060 -0.0462 0.116
May 2024 1098 0.0354 0.1039
Jun 2024 1124 0.0239 0.1222
Jul 2024 1121 -0.0025 0.1275
Aug 2024 1060 -0.0549 0.0579
Sep 2024 1060 0.0 0.0776
Oct 2024 1064 0.004 0.0699
Nov 2024 1064 -0.0004 0.0505
Dec 2024 1066 0.0019 -0.0345
Jan 2025 1083 0.0167 -0.0128
Feb 2025 1082 -0.001 -0.0145
Mar 2025 1017 -0.0603 -0.0851
Apr 2025 1028 0.0106 -0.0306
May 2025 1115 0.0846 0.0154
Jun 2025 1115 0.0003 -0.008
Jul 2025 1109 -0.0051 -0.0106
Aug 2025 1109 0.0 0.0469
Sep 2025 1101 -0.0079 0.0386
Oct 2025 1076 -0.0222 0.0115
Nov 2025 1110 0.0319 0.0442
Dec 2025 1125 0.0131 0.0558
Jan 2026 1151 0.0235 0.0629
Feb 2026 1153 0.0014 0.0654
Mar 2026 1135 -0.0158 0.1159