Zip Code: 11965 (Shelter Island Heights, NY) - Trend of Median House Listing Price Per Square Feet (Realtor)
Updated on March 13, 2026.

According to data from Realtor.com, the median house listing price per square feet for the 11965 Zip Code in February 2026 was $1,037. The month over month percentage change (MoM) was 0.038%, and the year over year percentage change (YoY) was -0.0899%.

You can see similar for other New York Zip Codes, and for New York.

The chart below shows the trend of the median house listing price per square feet in the 11965 zip code. The table below shows the trend of the median house listing price per square feet, and the MoM and YoY percentage changes.

Data Source: Realtor.
Zip Code: 11965 - Trend of Median House Listing Price Per Square Feet ($)
Zip Code: 11965 Trend of Median House Listing Price Per Square Feet
Items per page:
1 – 10 of 115
Month Price ($) MoM Perc. Change (%) YoY Perc. Change (%)
Aug 2016 884
Sep 2016 460
Oct 2016 438
Nov 2016 456
Dec 2016 408
Jan 2017 408
Feb 2017 1152
Mar 2017 1152
Apr 2017 1499
May 2017 1239
Jun 2017 1239
Jul 2017 1239
Aug 2017 1239 0.0 0.4016
Sep 2017 1239 0.0 1.691
Oct 2017 1239 0.0 1.8286
Nov 2017 1239 0.0 1.7147
Dec 2017 1239 0.0 2.0355
Jan 2018 1110 -0.1042 1.7192
Feb 2018 1110 0.0 -0.0366
Mar 2018 832 -0.2502 -0.2776
Apr 2018 554 -0.3336 -0.6303
May 2018 762 0.3748 -0.3847
Jun 2018 554 -0.2726 -0.5524
Jul 2018 554 0.0 -0.5524
Aug 2018 735 0.3251 -0.4069
Sep 2018 735 0.0 -0.4069
Oct 2018 735 0.0 -0.4069
Nov 2018 765 0.0415 -0.3824
Dec 2018 738 -0.0355 -0.4043
Jan 2019 738 0.0 -0.335
Feb 2019 700 -0.0513 -0.3691
Mar 2019 689 -0.0164 -0.1724
Apr 2019 646 -0.0623 0.1646
May 2019 602 -0.0671 -0.2097
Jun 2019 588 -0.023 0.0615
Jul 2019 639 0.085 0.1517
Aug 2019 588 -0.0784 -0.1989
Sep 2019 581 -0.0134 -0.2096
Oct 2019 569 -0.0204 -0.2257
Nov 2019 551 -0.0321 -0.2804
Dec 2019 541 -0.0164 -0.2662
Jan 2020 541 0.0 -0.2662
Feb 2020 494 -0.0868 -0.2936
Mar 2020 541 0.095 -0.2136
Apr 2020 588 0.0868 -0.0886
May 2020 588 0.0 -0.023
Jun 2020 588 0.0 0.0
Jul 2020 588 0.0 -0.0784
Aug 2020 588 0.0 0.0
Sep 2020 614 0.0431 0.0572
Oct 2020 862 0.4051 0.5163
Nov 2020 966 0.1205 0.7554
Dec 2020 966 0.0 0.7848
Jan 2021 966 0.0 0.7848
Feb 2021 966 0.0 0.9544
Mar 2021 902 -0.0664 0.6662
Apr 2021 819 -0.0928 0.391
May 2021 927 0.133 0.5759
Jun 2021 927 0.0 0.5759
Jul 2021 1080 0.1648 0.8356
Aug 2021 1409 0.3042 1.3941
Sep 2021 1060 -0.2474 0.7274
Oct 2021 1169 0.102 0.3549
Nov 2021 1508 0.2901 0.5599
Dec 2021 819 -0.4568 -0.1527
Jan 2022 1011 0.235 0.0465
Feb 2022 321 -0.683 -0.6683
Mar 2022 905 1.8226 0.0029
Apr 2022 905 0.0 0.1055
May 2022 905 0.0 -0.0243
Jul 2022 825 -0.2359
Aug 2022 1535 0.8594 0.0894
Sep 2022 1535 0.0 0.4474
Oct 2022 2244 0.4622 0.9205
Nov 2022 1801 -0.1976 0.1944
Dec 2022 2244 0.2463 1.7405
Jan 2023 2244 0.0 1.219
Feb 2023 2244 0.0 6.0002
Mar 2023 1811 -0.1931 1.0013
Apr 2023 2244 0.2392 1.4801
May 2023 2244 0.0 1.4801
Jun 2023 1340 -0.4027
Jul 2023 1340 0.0 0.6239
Aug 2023 1340 0.0 -0.1266
Sep 2023 1684 0.2562 0.0971
Oct 2023 1378 -0.1817 -0.386
Nov 2023 1378 0.0 -0.2348
Dec 2023 1378 0.0 -0.386
Jan 2024 1666 0.2089 -0.2577
Feb 2024 1666 0.0 -0.2577
Mar 2024 1173 -0.2959 -0.3523
Apr 2024 1378 0.1748 -0.386
May 2024 1666 0.2089 -0.2577
Jun 2024 1666 0.0 0.2427
Jul 2024 1666 0.0 0.2427
Aug 2024 1257 -0.2451 -0.0619
Sep 2024 1090 -0.1332 -0.3527
Oct 2024 1090 0.0 -0.2089
Nov 2024 1104 0.013 -0.1987
Dec 2024 1035 -0.063 -0.2491
Jan 2025 982 -0.0507 -0.4104
Feb 2025 1046 0.0653 -0.3718
Mar 2025 1139 0.0889 -0.0285
Apr 2025 1105 -0.0301 -0.198
May 2025 1211 0.096 -0.2729
Jun 2025 1105 -0.0876 -0.3366
Jul 2025 999 -0.096 -0.4003
Aug 2025 999 0.0 -0.2055
Sep 2025 1058 0.0593 -0.0292
Oct 2025 1117 0.056 0.0252
Nov 2025 1141 0.021 0.0333
Dec 2025 999 -0.1244 -0.0344
Jan 2026 999 0.0 0.0171
Feb 2026 999 0.0 -0.0452
Mar 2026 1037 0.038 -0.0899