Zip Code: 11965 (Shelter Island, New York) - Trend of Zillow Home Value Index (ZHVI) for All Homes (SFR, Condo/Co-op), Smooth and Seasonally Adjusted (Zillow)

Updated on March 22, 2026.

According to data from Zillow.com, the smoothed and seasonally adjusted Zillow home value index (ZHVI) for All Homes (SFR, Condo/Co-op) in the 11965 Zip Code (Shelter Island, New York) in February 2026 was $2,001,852.535. The month over month percentage change (MoM) was 0.26%, and the year over year percentage change (YoY) was 4.98%.

The chart below shows the trend of the smoothed and seasonally adjusted ZHVI for the 11965 zip code (Shelter Island, New York). The table below shows the trend of the smoothed and seasonally adjusted ZHVI, and the MoM and YoY percentage changes for the 11965 zip code (Shelter Island, New York).

You can see similar information for other New York zip codes, and for New York.

Note: Zillow Home Value Index (ZHVI) is a measure of the typical home value and market changes across a given region and housing type. It reflects the typical value for homes in the 35th to 65th percentile range.

Data Source: Zillow.
Zip Code: 11965 (Shelter Island, New York) - Trend of Zillow Home Value Index (ZHVI), Smooth and Seasonally Adjusted ($)
Zip Code: 11965 (Shelter Island, New York) - Trend of Zillow Home Value Index (ZHVI), Smooth and Seasonally Adjusted
1 – 10 of 134
Month ZHVI ($) MoM Perc. Change (%) YoY Perc. Change (%)
Jan 2015 929728.9322677152 -0.15 6.15
Feb 2015 928468.1014123227 -0.14 5.88
Mar 2015 928303.5011714507 -0.02 5.44
Apr 2015 932695.8456763633 0.47 5.24
May 2015 937041.9103408218 0.47 5.36
Jun 2015 942731.6386732478 0.61 5.71
Jul 2015 945775.9509389807 0.32 5.78
Aug 2015 955134.2463370133 0.99 6.26
Sep 2015 965453.2025231406 1.08 6.40
Oct 2015 978403.6355919791 1.34 6.64
Nov 2015 985590.0298150129 0.74 6.44
Dec 2015 986968.5428336273 0.14 6.00
Jan 2016 985942.0839595672 -0.10 6.05
Feb 2016 985314.9970064843 -0.06 6.12
Mar 2016 984724.718034273 -0.06 6.08
Apr 2016 987158.111785025 0.25 5.84
May 2016 990945.5975340739 0.38 5.75
Jun 2016 996510.7705428349 0.56 5.71
Jul 2016 1001692.6953402734 0.52 5.91
Aug 2016 1004470.1037353099 0.28 5.17
Sep 2016 1005757.3240543581 0.13 4.18
Oct 2016 1007972.2126620938 0.22 3.02
Nov 2016 1011243.4048093063 0.33 2.60
Dec 2016 1015377.6959667401 0.41 2.88
Jan 2017 1022237.8816147234 0.68 3.68
Feb 2017 1033302.4527021652 1.08 4.87
Mar 2017 1049996.894694886 1.62 6.63
Apr 2017 1064150.8974334283 1.35 7.80
May 2017 1073200.687245377 0.85 8.30
Jun 2017 1072250.3606872715 -0.09 7.60
Jul 2017 1072119.6270734684 -0.01 7.03
Aug 2017 1072328.6985688794 0.02 6.76
Sep 2017 1077476.2835799425 0.48 7.13
Oct 2017 1077701.286168803 0.02 6.92
Nov 2017 1073997.6332929675 -0.34 6.21
Dec 2017 1066392.5565288975 -0.71 5.02
Jan 2018 1058866.2342674441 -0.71 3.58
Feb 2018 1054141.8502972508 -0.45 2.02
Mar 2018 1054597.718668428 0.04 0.44
Apr 2018 1055218.618239758 0.06 -0.84
May 2018 1061418.9430840479 0.59 -1.10
Jun 2018 1067514.9510831789 0.57 -0.44
Jul 2018 1072831.7640764865 0.50 0.07
Aug 2018 1077504.973400494 0.44 0.48
Sep 2018 1079988.4816238428 0.23 0.23
Oct 2018 1089301.5127487574 0.86 1.08
Nov 2018 1096072.7946480622 0.62 2.06
Dec 2018 1103940.13931262 0.72 3.52
Jan 2019 1110916.8981349468 0.63 4.92
Feb 2019 1121365.7736677525 0.94 6.38
Mar 2019 1132792.6321894315 1.02 7.42
Apr 2019 1139375.6706766153 0.58 7.98
May 2019 1140720.123579675 0.12 7.47
Jun 2019 1143112.0846254562 0.21 7.08
Jul 2019 1147221.8916971886 0.36 6.93
Aug 2019 1149124.6687415298 0.17 6.65
Sep 2019 1142255.5733041025 -0.60 5.77
Oct 2019 1131987.3866125022 -0.90 3.92
Nov 2019 1121715.428832869 -0.91 2.34
Dec 2019 1117181.4068336065 -0.40 1.20
Jan 2020 1112971.7468399073 -0.38 0.19
Feb 2020 1111579.6805980082 -0.12 -0.87
Mar 2020 1109188.8617024682 -0.21 -2.08
Apr 2020 1110285.1878154597 0.10 -2.55
May 2020 1111134.9609633328 0.08 -2.59
Jun 2020 1112221.2427155764 0.10 -2.70
Jul 2020 1110683.8348233586 -0.14 -3.18
Aug 2020 1109586.198471669 -0.10 -3.44
Sep 2020 1113519.926923537 0.36 -2.52
Oct 2020 1124895.906201373 1.02 -0.63
Nov 2020 1146818.794674623 1.95 2.24
Dec 2020 1175972.7134631292 2.54 5.26
Jan 2021 1205144.74767303 2.48 8.28
Feb 2021 1232993.4390347123 2.31 10.92
Mar 2021 1255272.0246337869 1.81 13.17
Apr 2021 1283997.0709561768 2.29 15.65
May 2021 1321717.9605819378 2.94 18.95
Jun 2021 1365229.1024917476 3.29 22.75
Jul 2021 1407170.261833241 3.07 26.69
Aug 2021 1440845.8548394106 2.39 29.85
Sep 2021 1469424.5701163185 1.98 31.96
Oct 2021 1497490.1107119329 1.91 33.12
Nov 2021 1524004.0959212703 1.77 32.89
Dec 2021 1547025.0445251644 1.51 31.55
Jan 2022 1563750.6614684637 1.08 29.76
Feb 2022 1575885.3814770791 0.78 27.81
Mar 2022 1596325.2668603072 1.30 27.17
Apr 2022 1623998.1197056805 1.73 26.48
May 2022 1657857.1230680384 2.09 25.43
Jun 2022 1692736.1463137371 2.10 23.99
Jul 2022 1719469.8650863182 1.58 22.19
Aug 2022 1729625.1032867236 0.59 20.04
Sep 2022 1725309.3280526327 -0.25 17.41
Oct 2022 1721223.370169033 -0.24 14.94
Nov 2022 1723549.4016564924 0.14 13.09
Dec 2022 1723796.8636450071 0.01 11.43
Jan 2023 1711448.989763717 -0.72 9.45
Feb 2023 1698022.483337772 -0.78 7.75
Mar 2023 1691119.4043557253 -0.41 5.94
Apr 2023 1698517.9708406841 0.44 4.59
May 2023 1714222.635935058 0.93 3.40
Jun 2023 1730353.4583261646 0.94 2.22
Jul 2023 1746914.9614823454 0.96 1.60
Aug 2023 1758827.5864291769 0.68 1.69
Sep 2023 1776912.034947037 1.03 2.99
Oct 2023 1794792.861442865 1.01 4.27
Nov 2023 1811614.4524655326 0.94 5.11
Dec 2023 1820378.9439912436 0.48 5.60
Jan 2024 1822449.3225176716 0.11 6.49
Feb 2024 1825451.080756252 0.17 7.51
Mar 2024 1834761.6155513313 0.51 8.49
Apr 2024 1852698.3424367236 0.98 9.08
May 2024 1866833.1232177075 0.76 8.90
Jun 2024 1878008.4619938626 0.60 8.53
Jul 2024 1885543.5809072747 0.40 7.94
Aug 2024 1899549.4782447538 0.74 8.00
Sep 2024 1913288.1473804647 0.72 7.68
Oct 2024 1920629.0359217282 0.38 7.01
Nov 2024 1918418.9065392108 -0.11 5.90
Dec 2024 1912294.346594369 -0.32 5.05
Jan 2025 1908640.8841073457 -0.19 4.73
Feb 2025 1906874.1266916904 -0.09 4.46
Mar 2025 1905528.2822118874 -0.07 3.86
Apr 2025 1910719.6451614453 0.27 3.13
May 2025 1921243.7098927374 0.55 2.92
Jun 2025 1934262.777286668 0.68 3.00
Jul 2025 1943584.2679593284 0.48 3.08
Aug 2025 1949031.2504616405 0.28 2.61
Sep 2025 1959393.9040860904 0.53 2.41
Oct 2025 1969319.0337573297 0.51 2.54
Nov 2025 1981673.5502623923 0.63 3.30
Dec 2025 1988799.5519730214 0.36 4.00
Jan 2026 1996582.8936153864 0.39 4.61
Feb 2026 2001852.5347189128 0.26 4.98